Actuarial Audits

Due diligence requires that pension plan fiduciaries and plan sponsors exercise prudence in selecting service providers such as actuaries, and monitor the quality of their work. An actuarial audit is a valuable tool for monitoring the quality of actuarial services performed on behalf of the pension plan.

An actuarial audit involves engaging the services of an outside actuary (reviewing actuary) to scrutinize the work of the plan’s consulting actuary.[1] Actuarial audits are helpful for several reasons:

1. They enhance the credibility of the actuarial valuation process by providing independent assurance that it was performed in accordance with actuarial standards of practice;
2. They increase public trust in how the pension plan is being governed;
3. They help plan fiduciaries to assess whether the pension plan is meeting its funding objectives;
4. They can lead to the remediation of errors that might otherwise go undiscovered; and
5. They can provide recommendations for improving the actuarial valuation process, including how information is presented in the actuarial valuation report and in other communications.

Actuarial audits are not all the same. Various levels of actuarial audits are distinguished from one another by the types of services performed by the reviewing actuary.

1. In a level one, or “full-scope,” actuarial audit, the reviewing actuary fully replicates the original actuarial valuation, based on the same census data, assumptions, and actuarial methods used by the plan’s consulting actuary. In addition, the reviewing actuary examines the consulting actuary’s methods and assumptions for reasonableness and internal consistency.
2. In a level two actuarial audit, the reviewing actuary does not fully replicate the consulting actuary’s valuation, but instead uses a sampling of the plan’s participant data to test the results of the valuation. The reviewing actuary also examines the consulting actuary’s methods and assumptions for reasonableness and internal consistency.
3. In a level three actuarial audit, the reviewing actuary examines the consulting actuary’s methods and assumptions for reasonableness and internal consistency, but does not perform actuarial calculations.

Often when a new consulting actuary is engaged the new consulting actuary performs a full replication of the previous actuarial valuation to establish a baseline. This practice, when feasible,[3] is highly encouraged.